What do nuns, Nazis, and a nanny with a penchant for Solfège have to teach us about survival and resistance? Quite a lot, it turns out. On the History For F***k’s Sake podcast, we chat to Canadian conductor and cultural leader Robin Thomas to pull back the curtain on The Sound of Music. But don’t be fooled: this isn’t just a nostalgic singalong, it’s a deep-dive into how music, heritage, and personal memory intertwine, shaping both individual lives and collective history.

Do-Re-Mi, Defiance, and Displacement

The episode opens in 1965, a world reeling from war and stepping gingerly into the Cold War era. Here, The Sound of Music bursts onto the scene, cloaking tough topics in sumptuous melodies. As host, Sarah puts it, “behind the ‘do re mi’ lies a deeper truth. This is a story about survival, resistance, and how we costume our trauma in melody.”

Robin brings a unique perspective, shaped by his South African roots and Canadian upbringing. He describes his own family’s migration from apartheid-era South Africa to Canada, detailing how the arts, especially music provided both escape and connection. For Robin, The Sound of Music is personal: he first encountered the film as a child, its narrative about leaving home to protect family echoing his own family’s story. “It really resonates to this day,” Robin admits, his voice catching with emotion.

Music as Memory, Music as Resistance

Throughout the conversation, Sarah and Robin reflect on how heritage musicals like The Sound of Music use historical backdrops not only for spectacle but for storytelling with substance. Robin argues that the best musical theatre wraps “complicated geopolitical and emotional themes” in “exquisite, timeless tunes.” Even if a musical takes creative liberties, he says, “it doesn’t need to literally be true to be the truth.”

They also touch on the importance of participation in the arts as a means of processing personal and collective trauma. For Robin, conducting and listening to music creates space for introspection and connection within oneself, with others, and across time. He recounts a moving episode conducting Brahms’ German Requiem after the death of his grandmother, describing how music provided “comfort and healing and growing through grief.”

Building Bridges and Busting Myths

Sarah and Robin both take aim at the myth that history and culture exist in separate spheres. Instead, they insist, arts and heritage are constantly shaping one another, forming a story that is “a circle … not two separate spheres.” This point resonates especially through their discussion of migration and  how stories like the von Trapp family’s, and the real-life experience of welcoming refugees and immigrants, form threads binding together global communities.

Come From Away, another Canadian musical set against the backdrop of 9/11, gets a loving shoutout as they explore how musical theatre captures “the emotion, the humanity” of historic moments, finding hope in these musical retellings of difficult times.

Connection in a Noisy World

We discuss why connecting through art, honest conversation, and simple acts of being present is so important. Robin laments the pressures of modern life, where “never ending stimuli” make it easy to lose touch with both each other and ourselves. Yet, whether it’s by sitting quietly with music or sharing long, rambling conversations, we both agree on the value of “meaningful discussions … about the meaning of things.”

So next time you hum “Edelweiss” or catch a matinee of The Sound of Music, remember: these songs aren’t just entertainment. They are bridges linking us to the past, to each other, and to the deeper truths that sometimes, only music can reveal.

Listen to the full episode [Link] for more insights, stories, and a bit of joyful nerdiness because our stories (and our songs) really do matter.

Tags: