GUEST: NICK HEWITT, NAVAL HISTORIAN & JAWS FAN

When people talk about Jaws, they remember the iconic theme, the sun-soaked suspense, and those black, lifeless eyes. But 50 years on, it’s Quint’s bone-chilling monologue that haunts fans and few realise that speech is rooted in a true-life tragedy of epic and nearly forgotten proportions.

In this episode of History for F***’s Sake, we welcome naval historian Nick Hewitt to explore the story beneath the story: the sinking of the USS Indianapolis in the summer of 1945, and the horror that unfolded when over 1,100 sailors plunged into the Pacific, unrescued and alone, after delivering the Hiroshima bomb.

Nick shares how he first got swept up in maritime history (thanks, Dad and a stack of naval novels), and together we revisit Jaws: its troubled production, why you barely see the shark, and why pop culture so often turns lived horror into legendary storytelling. But what really matters, Nick says, is that drama, when done right, hooks us emotionally and leads a new generation to dig for real answers.

We break down what actually happened aboard the Indianapolis, why the Navy’s overconfidence led to delayed rescue, the mechanics of survival and loss at sea, and why the truth is so much grimmer than even Spielberg imagined. Nick’s take? “It’s not a story about sharks, it’s a story about war, memory, and what we choose to forget.”

The episode also marks the 250th anniversary of the US Navy, letting us spotlight both the Navy’s proudest legacies and its darkest hours. We talk favourite films (hello, Crimson Tide and Top Gun, what Hollywood owes to history, and why now, perhaps more than ever, we need real stories to help us face the anxieties and complexities of our world.

As Nick puts it: “Pop culture grips you with the essence of history. It’s a bridge and it’s our job to help people cross it and discover what’s real.”

If you’ve ever shuddered at Jaws, wondered about the line between memory and myth, or just love a salty tale of survival against impossible odds, this episode is for you.

Tags: